UNIGIS logo and link to UNIGIS UK

 

  Master of Science  
  MSc Study Guide  
  UK Staff  
  MSc Forum  
     
  Resource Centre  
  Registered Students  
 
  UNIGIS UK  
Image: Registered Students - MSc

MSc  Abstracts 1998

Norman Bird

Managing Enterprise GI Using Intranets


Godefridus Cattenstart

Boundaries in GIS, Open GIS and the SDO and SDE Implementation

In 1994 the Open GIS Consortium (OGC) was launched with the mission of improving the interoperability of GIS. At the heart of this mission was a need to find a common standard for the structuring of topological features, among which the structuring in a SQL environment. This common standard has evolved in to OGC "Simple Features Specification for SQL". However, from a practical point of view this specification is only of value once it is embodied within systems that are used in practice. In 1997 two major commercial packages came on the market. ORACLE Corporation Spatial Data Option (SDO) and Environmental Systems Research Institute Spatial Data Engine (SDE). Both with the intention of using the OGC standards as the basic building block for structuring vector databases.

The main aim of this thesis was to evaluate how well SDO and SDE apply the OGC specification and furthermore establish whether or not the practical application of these tools and standards meets the needs of users for the topological structuring of geographic data. To do this a case study data set from the Dienst Landelijk Gebied in the Netherlands was implemented in both SDO and SDE. The next set of four major aspects were found.

Simple and non simple geometries can be incorporated in SDO and SDE. However, not all OGC simple geometries are supported and more importantly many non simple topological structures are not accommodated at all. OGC is recommended to address rules on conversion of non simple to simple geometries.

SDO and SDE differ greatly in their set of geometry validation rules and the way they interpret the OGC specification. This means that both systems will react differently when data are inserted. Inserting the same set of data in both packages might result in different implementations in both packages.is a most unwanted situation. Standards on converting non-simple geometries is of great importance.

The storage architecture and physical data structure of SDO, in numeric format, and SDE, in binary format, is in accordance with the OGC specification. Storage format in itself is not that much a users concern. However, in order to compose efficient retrieval statements the user must have knowledge about the implemented data structure of geometry’s and the spatial indexing mechanism.

Retrieval of data in SDO and SDE is highly bound to the concepts of the developers. In SDO this is a full SQL integrated environment. In SDE it is a defined Application Program interface. Retrieval is an aspect OGC is recommended to address.

From a user's point the positive message is that with proper care, spatial data, can be incorporated, managed and set available in both packages, following the rules of OpenGIS. Still there is much work to be done before the OGC specification and its implementation in products like SDO and SDE will provide GIS products which are truly interoperable in character.


Tony Coatsworth

Developing a GIS for Overhead Asset Maintenance in the Electricity Distribution Industry

Electricity is supplied from the National Grid, to industry and to our homes, via a network of substations, overhead lines and underground cables. The reliability and performance of this network has to meet certain standards set down by government, as well as efficiently delivering electrical units on behalf of the supply companies. Therefore, electrical distribution companies who operate these networks need to run various support systems – both computer and paper based, to help them manage their networks.

This study examines how Geographical Information Systems (GIS) can be used to manage the process of asset maintenance – in particular for the sections of overhead network which are exposed to the elements and are more prone to faults and damage.

Many UK electrical distribution companies are using GIS for various purposes including asset maintenance and this study will review some of these systems.

NORWEB Distribution – an electricity distribution company in the North West of England currently use a GIS system – OHMS (Over Head Management System) which is essentially a map management system. This study will explore how this system could be extended by using ‘GIS-type’ functionality, to produce a tool for managing the overhead asset maintenance process.

It will demonstrate how the digital asset data already captured can be linked to other data sets, and by using spatial queries, to present this information in a useful form to the Network Operations section. It will also review data quality issues and make recommendations on how this might by improved.


Fred Finch

A geocoded Address Database for Ireland


Margaret Jones

Spatial Decision Support for the Planning of Large Transport Infrastructure Projects

Decision-making for large transport infrastructure projects is largely a spatial problem. Geographic Information Systems have already been used for functions such as technical planning and for preparing environmental impact predictions. There were some limitations to this approach: the cost in time and money (design of the system, data gathering), the need for powerful computers and scarce specialist expertise. The general public was sceptical of technical presentations which were not easy for the layman to understand.

Decision-making and conflict as experienced in the planning of the Betuwe freight railway in the Netherlands were examined. A research GIS was assembled using off-the-shelf hardware and software, and data supplied by the province of Gelderland (representing one half of the total route of the railway). It was demonstrated that many of the crucial spatial issues within decision-making and conflict resolution could be handled within this system, as could issues within the field of Environmental Impact Assessment.

However, the history of the case showed that although GIS was used as a tool by the developer to prepare technical presentations, and to prepare the EIA report, communication with the public was poorly managed; public meetings aroused much opposition to the project.

Drawing together conclusions from the research GIS, from the history of the planning of the railway and from present development in Geographic Information Technology in general, it is proposed that GIT can now be used more effectively in such cases.

First, the constant improvement of off-the-shelf hardware and software, the growing availability of digital spatial data and of the expertise built up in the application of spatial systems mean that the cost in time and money of assembling such a system is reduced. Second, open and organised use of GIT can allow better communication and transparency in decision-making, better collaboration amongst decision-makers and improved public participation. The EIA procedure within the Netherlands provides a possible organisational framework within which GIT could operate. The EIA requirement for monitoring environmental effects during construction and operation can also be handled using a GIS. Third, GIS combined with virtual reality techniques allow much better public presentation and participation. Also developments towards Open GIS make it possible to link individual systems having specific functions (technical planning, decision-making, EIA, public communication) into a distributed system, so that changes in one area are immediately updated throughout the system, and all stakeholders can have access to current information.


David Kidd

Using Geographical Information Systems to Investigate Patterns of Intraspecific Variation in Ephippiger Ephippiger (Orthoptera, Tettigonidea)

Spatial intraspecific variation patterns arise through the evolutionary processes of natural selection and genetic drift acting within the constraints of the environment and population history. Complex patterns of variation are observed in the cricket Ephippiger ephippiger (Saddle-backed Bushcricket) in South-west France. These complex patterns have resulted in considerable debate over their origin and the taxonomic status of the organism. Here, E. ephippiger trait and environmental data sets are integrated and compared using the Idrisi and MapInfo Geographical Information Systems (GIS). Inverse distance surfaces are generated for each trait and analysed through a variety of uni-, bi- and multivariate statistical and mapping techniques. Four simple component pattern types are revealed which can be combined in different ways to produce the observed trait patterns. An evolutionary history hypothesis is constructed from the relationships between the intraspecific variation patters, environment, landscape and the post-glacial history of Western Europe.


Ian Lamont

The Potential Use of Geographical Information Systems in Computer Assisted Mass Appraisal: The Digital Elevation Model

The use of Geographical Information Systems (GIS) within property valuation and mass appraisal has yet to be fully realised within the United Kingdom. GIS technology provides the ability to measure proximity and location and thus provides a natural support tool for Computer Assisted Mass Appraisal (CAMA).

Using empirical data on a study area of Carrickfergus, Northern Ireland, this project investigates how GIS can provide a credible support tool for mass appraisals. More importantly it investigates how the spatial element of GIS can allow location to be modelling as an indice and applied as a factor using residual error. Investigation incorporates a selection of common surface interpolation techniques and assesses the potential of ‘Value Influence Centres, how these are located, measured and applied to improve predictive quality. This work compares the surface based predictions with the more familiar mass appraisal techniques of multiple regression models. In conclusion, a series of procedural refinements are discussed an recommended for future research.


Gernot Paulus

Application of Geographical Information Systems to Exploration and Evaluation of Hydrocarbon and Geothermal Resources in Sedimentary Basins

Subsurface fluid migration is a multi parameter process depending on a lot of different components like, e.g., tectonics, facies, lithology, hydrochemistry and hydraulics and is a key component of petroleum and geothermal exploration and production in sedimentary basins. The area of investigation is the Molasse Basin in Upper Austria which is a typical asymmetric, compressional foreland basin at the northern margin of the Alps. Due to petroleum exploration and production there exists an excellent data set of more than 500 wells ranging in depth from 1000m to 4000m. Three different fault systems have been active at different times from pre-Tertiary till present and have a large impact on hydrocarbon migration and fluid flow. There exist two components of fluid migration:

  1. N-directed migration of hydrocarbons and
  2. E-directed fluid flow of deep groundwater at basin scale in a Jurassic carbonate aquifer which is the main target for geothermal exploration in this area.

A Geographical Information System (GIS) has been use d(1) to integrate different data sets available using their geographic location as the common frame of reference and (2) to perform spatial analysis on this comprehensive data base. The data sets used for the spatial analysis are well data, subsurface fault data, hydrocarbon reservoir data, a high resolution Digital Terrain Model(DTM) and LANDSAT satellite lineaments. The applications of spatial GIS analysis techniques presented in this paper are:

  1. investigations of spatial relationship between subsurface faults and well locations using buffer zones and topological overlay,
  2. calculation of fault density and its implication of subsurface fluid flow,
  3. modelling fluid flow using cost surfaces,
  4. spatial overlay between hydrocarbon reservoirs and fault-related permeability distribution,
  5. determination of zones of high potential of vertical fault-related aquifer connectivity by comparing topographic lineaments extracted from a DTM with subsurface faults and
  6. quality check of existing LANDSAT satellite lineaments using a DTM.


Nico Piquer

A Cost/Benefit Analysis for the Use of GIS within Dutch Water Boards

Within Dutch water boards there is a growing suspicion towards costly developments in Information Technology. If this point of view becomes generally accepted, it will act as a brake on the introduction of new GIS-applications. In order to counterweight this, an investigation on costs and benefits of new GIS-applications in Dutch water boards is carried out.

Developments are generally determined by environmental circumstances. Information on the relevant influences within water boards, together with information on modern attitudes towards organisation development and IT/GIS, places these developments in the righ perspective.

New applications within water boards also emerge because of ongoing technological developments. Without going too much in details, background information on important developments in provided to be able to conceive how future applications might work.

Water boards employ a manifold of automated and manual systems on facilities information. An overview of all relevant systems, followed by worked-out descriptions of possible new GIS-applications, provides the basis for the research. As expected from the general characteristics of water board’s processes, emphasis is on communication and integration.

Since the decision on new application lies with the water boards, they are invited to give the opinion on benefits and priorities by means of questionnaires and interviews. This phase also provides more in-depth information on their feelings towards and possible new applications.

Since the objective is, to end up with costs and benefits of new applications, the information on priorities and benefits are completed with costs, to provide an overview of applications which the water boards consider to be feasible and necessary.

The intention is, to provide a more or less general overview by gathering information from different water boards. This approach automatically results in limitations because of the limited scope of the information collected. All limitations perceived are addressed, and if possible indications for improvement and future research and provided.


Joanna Robinson

An Investigation into the Factors Affecting the Implementation of a GIS in Secondary Schools

This research project investigates the factors which influence the successful implementation of a Geographical Information System (GIS) in a secondary school. The factors generally affecting the implementation of GIS in organisations are considered. These are divided into four categories covering technical, financial, organisation and user issues. The research approach and methods are described and the research objectives defined. A case study, Cheltenham College, an independent school, where GIS is being used as a tool to assist in the teaching of geographical concepts at Key Stage 3 and 4 of the National Curriculum for Geography for England and Wales, is used to investigate the use of GIS in secondary schools. The development and use of IT and GIS in the case study are recorded. The results of research on the case study are logged and analysed with respect to the previously described categories of factors affecting implementation of GIS. These are further analysed in the broader context of other educational and other types of organisations. Finally, the future possible development and use of GIS in schools in general and in Cheltenham College are discussed.

Top of pageTop of page

 

Educating GI Professionals Worldwide
| MSc Home | MSc Study Guide | UK Staff | Resource Centre
| Registered Students | UK homepage | International homepage | Disclaimer | About this site
Copyright ©UNIGIS. UNIGIS is a Registered Trademark. For Comments please Email Webmaster